The Front Page: The case for media reparations 

It’s Friday, October 9.

This time on The Front Page: Media 2070, an overdue apology, and a few union wins.

This edition is by Holly Piepenburg and Gabe Schneider with editing by Curtis Yee.

What do media reparations look like? 

“Can newsrooms reconcile and repair the harms they have caused? And can we count on the same profit-driven, white-owned corporate media institutions to fully integrate their newsrooms and allow Black journalistic brilliance to rise half a century after failing to heed the Kerner Commission’s recommendations to do so?”

These are the questions asked by Media 2070, a provocative essay that asks journalists to consider what media reparations look like after generations of exclusionary media and white centric coverage. The authors are direct in their accurate condemnation: 

“Media organizations were complicit in the slave trade and profited off of chattel slavery; a powerful newspaper publisher helped lead the deadly overthrow of a local government in Wilmington, North Carolina, where Black people held power; racist journalism has led to countless lynchings; southern broadcast stations have opposed integration; and, in the 21st century, powerful social media and tech companies are allowing white supremacists to use their platforms to organize, fundraise, recruit and spread hate.”

The series of essays were co-created by a collective of Black staff at Free Press, an organization that has advocated for public funding of media and stronger media accountability. More specifically, the project was compiled and created by Joseph Torres, Tauhid Chappell, Alicia Bell, Diamond Hardiman, Collette Watson, and Christina Pierce

“I think for us, 2070 is not so much about that actual date on the calendar in a temporal sense, for me anyway, but more so the idea that if we live in that future now, those are the ideas that we need to sustain us so that we can see 2070 and beyond,” Watson, one of the co-authors, said in an interview with MuckRack. “Inhabiting a future of media, but in this time, could actually get us to where we really needed to be yesterday.”

You can read the full 100-page essay here. 

“We apologize for The Times’ history of racism”

Late last month, the Los Angeles Times went beyond the abundance of diversity and inclusion pledges introduced by media companies this summer. In an editorial, they apologize for their history as “an institution deeply rooted in white supremacy” initiated by founding publisher Harrison Gray Otis and upheld by (an overwhelmingly white) staff over the paper’s 138-year history. 

The Times’reckoning with racism,” as the piece is titled by the editorial board, also includes stories from current and former staffers who recount racism toward Black, Latino, and Asian American journalists and Angelenos at large. It’s unlikely that this comprehensive response would have been presented had staffers and members of the LAT guild not confronted newsroom leaders in June.

Likewise, the recent planned departure of Executive Editor Norman Pearlstine came only after Black and Latino journalists at the Times openly criticized the publication’s racist coverage and indefensible hiring and retention practices. Coupled with the recognition of the paper’s failures, it’s a start to correcting decades of damage, but there are already obvious holes in the Times’ transition.

Moreover, less than two weeks after the apology, it appears that the Times has already fallen back on old habits with both their coverage and internal management problems. While one can hope that the paper’s commitments will serve as a non-performative blueprint for other organizations, these actions are not promising.

New Yorker Union’s picket becomes a rally

On the night of their scheduled digital picket, the New Yorker Union ended the era of at-will employment with a “Just Cause” agreement, a provision that requires employers to adhere to an established standard when disciplining or firing employees. 

Preceding the agreement, Sen. Elizabeth Warren and Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, who were both slated to speak on the day of the strike, pulled out of the New Yorker Festival in support of the union. If you want to help, find out how you can show solidarity as the union fights for a contract here.

On the West Coast, the Seattle Times Digital Union is now part of Pacific Northwest Newspaper Guild following a unanimous vote in late September. Before the vote, the National Labor Relations Board denied an appeal from the Seattle Times Company, which sought to prevent the alliance. 

And, after months of combating racism, discrimination, and sexual harassment, WAMU’s content staff is unionizing with SAG-AFTRA. With this announcement, the union hopes to establish pay equity, “set actionable plans to retain and grow a diverse staff,” and better support employees that don’t work full time. Leaders have not yet voluntarily recognized the union, which would allow staff a seat at the bargaining table.

What is The Objective? 

The Objective is a publication meant to confront the inequities in journalism that are rooted in the notion of “objectivity” since the 1950s and continue today. To that end, we publish reporting, first-person commentary, and reported essays on how journalism has interacted with historically-ignored communities in terms of hiring and retention in newsrooms, as well as coverage.

We are an all-volunteer collective, several of us with full-time jobs outside of this work. But we believe this kind of coverage is not an occasional way to cover journalism, but the focal point. 

If you’re interested in pitching to us, you can read more about our process here. All pitches should be sent to [email protected] 

Your worst advice

As Objective contributor Johanna Alonso reported in her latest piece, journalists giving career advice to early-career journalists over Twitter isn’t always that helpful. So, we asked early-career journalists: What’s the worst advice you’ve ever received? Here are some of the responses

ICYMI at The Objective

What’s happening

*$$$ denotes a paid event

  • 0 days untilThe Online News Association’s annual conference ($$$). ONA 2020 runs until October 16

  • 4 days until A conversation with ‘trailblazing’ journalist Dorothy Gilliam,” the first Black woman reporter at the Washington Post. Questions for Gilliam can be submitted before the virtual event.

  • 5 days until … The Reuters Institute’s webinar on data bias in journalism. The conversation features Safiya Noble, a professor at UCLA. Register here.

  • 5 days untilCovering the Movement: An online forum for southern organizers and journalists on covering protest, voting rights, and COVID, hosted by Press On and the Highlander Center.

  • 6 days until … a hands-on Google tools training hosted by RTDNA. Mike Reilly, an SPJ digital trainer, will lead the workshop.

A bit more media

“Defector is a white revolution”

David Dennis Jr. writes that Defector, a publication started after Deadspin staffer were told to “stick to sports,” has no excuse for launching with only one Black staffer on its masthead. Ironically, Dennis also notes that many of Deadspin’s new hires, including “high-level editors and writers,” are Black.

California Sunday suspends publication

On Monday, Emerson Collective pulled funding from Pop-Up Magazine Productions. As a result, California Sunday magazine is suspending publication after having moved to digital-only in June. According to the Pop-Up / California Sunday Guild, 11 employees across the two publications have been laid off.

Chicago Magazine update

More than a month after she called out Chicago magazine for racism, Taylor Moore’s name has been removed from the publication’s masthead. According to Moore, the magazine has still not reached out, even as other journalists continue to highlight problems at the publication.

Furloughs at Essence

Citing revenue losses from COVID-19, Essence magazine put an uncertain number of employees on furlough last week. Medical benefits will continue throughout the period, which is not expected to exceed six months. 

Newsletters aren’t new

Mimeographs were the Substack of the mid-20th century when writers ditched traditional media to become their own publishers. Free of editors and benefiting from a general distrust of newspapers, underrepresented writers and leftist journalists carved out a relatively profitable profession until the late ’70s. 

Pittsburgh Post Gazette

After being barred from covering “one of the biggest civil rights movements of our lifetime,” Alexis Johnson has resigned from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. In a Twitter thread, Johnson says the paper hindered her professional growth and that she will continue to support the Newspaper Guild of Pittsburgh.

And finally, a few resources

Looking for a job? Here are a few places to look: INN | ONA | | 10 Jobs and a Dog | NABJ | AAJA | NAHJ | NLGJA | @WritersofColor | MEO Jobs | StudyHall XYZ | Opportunities of the Week ($)   

How about a style guide? Trans Journalist Association | Diversity Style Guide | NAJA Reporting and Indigenous Terminology Guide | NABJ Style Guide | Disability Language Style Guide | AAJA Guide to Covering Asian America | NAHJ Cultural Competence Handbook

Thanks for reading. We’ll have more for you soon. 

The Objective only operates with support from readers like you. Support us today and get your donation matched up to 12x!

Support The Objective and get your donation matched up to 24x!

Get your donation matched up to 24x!

We want to change journalism — but we need your help. Your support will ensure we can continue to provide a space for media criticism that other outlets won’t publish.

This site uses cookies to provide you with a great user experience. By continuing to use this website, you consent to the use of cookies in accordance with our privacy policy.

Scroll to Top